小木虫葵花宝典之外刊投稿书信大全-第贰辑
摘要: 小 木 虫 出 品小木虫葵花宝典之外刊投稿书信大全第贰辑【小木虫论坛本书编写组】shwh 整理打造小木虫出品必属精品##########NextPage########## 目 录前言………………………………………………………………………… ...
42
Please indicate whether the manuscript meets each of the following criteria: Are significant new results reported? Yes If portions of the work have been previously reported, does the present manuscript represent a <i>substantial</i> extension of the work? Yes Is the manuscript likely to be of interest to a reasonable number of organic chemists? Yes Are the conclusions adequately supported by the data presented? Yes Are the compounds reported adequately characterized with regard to identity and purity? Yes Are the literature references appropriate and correct? Yes Is the manuscript written clearly and concisely in idiomatic English? Yes Rate the overall Importance of this paper to the field of Organic Chemistry 5 - Highly Important / 1 - Unimportant: 3 Recommendation: Publish after minor revisions noted below. Additional Comments: page 2 : are aryl triflate really not commercially available ? Can be available if necessary page 2 : mistake : "phosphors" : phosphor page 2 : mistake " aryaltion" : arylation page 4 : please explain what molecular solvent means General questions : do you have homogeneous medium in the ionic liquid ? could you comment on this ? Do you have checked the E/Z ratio and the regioselectivity of the arylation during time (from 0h to 24h) ? A graphic representation would be fine to see. Sincerely, XXXXXXXXXX Associate Editor, The Journal of Organic Chemistry |
关闭
站长推荐
站长推荐
/5 
川公网安备 51200202000012